This skirt did exactly for me what I wanted it to. It was a quick throw on, on vacation to go into places that needed my knees covered (temples) over my regular clothes. Having the 3 different button settings helped a lot depending on what I was wearing underneath and how high I wanted it to sit. The fabric is lovely. Not too stiff, but with some texture and a nice shine. I did wear this for more formal dinners as well and did not feel out of place. Overall the style is a bit of retro though.
I'm not a fan of the length. I'm 5'8 and it hits me mid calf. I would like it to be a bit longer to go to about top of ankles.

I love the weight and drap of this skirt. I did size up as I like to wear skirts lower on my hips instead of my waist which is high. Highly recommend!

I got this as a mystery item, and couldn't be more pleased. It is probably one of the most versatile pieces. It goes over most of my dresses, with t-shirts or anything you'd wear with jeans, or with nice tops to be somewhat dressy. I moved the rear buttons closer to the seam. Maybe it should have been sized up, but it really didn't matter.

I had wanted another dress, but realized that having a skirt would be more versatile with my lovely wool& tops, so I took the plunge. The wrap is fantastic, the pockets are roomy and practical. I have large child-bearing hips and went with the hip measurement on the garment guide and love the fit! I also love how sturdy, but soft the fabric is.

I waited and waited for this to go on sale and it never did, sooo I bit the bullet and made the purchase, and am so glad I did. It works great on my wide hips and long legs.
The only issue I have is that the closest button is a wee bit too far away. But an XL would be too big. So I wish it had maybe, three buttons to choose from instead of two.